Can I Handle An Uninsured Motorist Injury Claim Myself?

December 21, 2020

The quick answer is sure you can. Your insurance policy has provisions that deal with the possibility that you or a family member driving your car will be hit by a driver with no insurance, or not enough insurance. Your insurance company, complying with Illinois state law, covers you as if you are making a claim against the other driver. It is then the right of your insurance company to try to get whatever money they pay to you in compensation back from the uninsured driver. Good luck to them. And that’s exactly why the State has made UM coverage mandatory. It’s very hard and very frustrating trying to collect money personally from an uninsured driver!


Now, I said earlier that you CAN try to handle a claim yourself, but there are many complications, twists, and turns that may make it much more advantageous for you to have an experienced uninsured motorist attorney on your side. Without getting into all the technicalities, every case is different; insurance companies have different claims procedures outlined in their policies, the process of arbitration rather than third-party suit has both procedural and time limits, and medical subrogation, if there is subrogation, varies from case to case. And finally, the insurance adjuster who is cooperative and friendly to you may not be making you an offer to settle that reflects the value of your claim. They know that.



Call me for a straightforward appraisal of the lay of the land. I’m happy to give you my opinion, based on thirty years of uninsured motorist, underinsured motorist, and hit and run claim experience. Michael Mannis (312) 704-4300.

Woman holding a smartphone near a white car with a driver visible through the window
October 12, 2026
Learn who may be liable for an Uber or Lyft accident in Illinois, how insurance coverage works, and how Mannis Injury Law helps Chicago injury victims.
Rider’s view from a motorcycle on a sunlit road, hands on handlebars and mirror visible
June 3, 2026
May marks Motorcycle Safety Awareness Month, a nationwide effort to remind drivers and riders that safer roads rely on everyone working together.
Busy city street with heavy traffic and many cars under traffic lights and tall buildings
June 3, 2026
Distracted driving remains a major cause of serious crashes, and proving it requires far more than suspicion.
Inside a BMW, driver’s view of steering wheel, dashboard, and navigation screen on the road
June 3, 2026
Many drivers wonder whether adding a dash cam is worth the investment
Two people standing with a striped carry-on suitcase in an airport or transit terminal
June 3, 2026
Spring break offers a welcome chance to unwind, explore somewhere new, and spend quality time with friends or family.
Two cars in a rear-end collision, a blue sedan hitting a silver car on a road with trees behind them.
June 3, 2026
Being involved in a car accident is difficult enough, but the situation becomes even more overwhelming when the other driver doesn’t have insurance.
Snowy road with a car driving away between snow-covered trees
June 3, 2026
Winter weather creates unpredictable and often hazardous conditions for anyone on the road.
Two cars with heavy front-end crash damage, black car facing a silver car in a parking lot.
October 4, 2024
Your Rights as a Rideshare Passenger in an Accident: What You Need to Know
Person holding a smartphone on a blurred city street at dusk
September 10, 2024
Injured as a Passenger in an Uber or Lyft? Here’s What You Need to Know About Your Rights
Red emergency vehicle with flashing lights driving through a city street
January 23, 2021
Fire Trucks Outside My Apt Today!